1. Health
Send to a Friend via Email

Product Review: Mederma for Scars

User Rating 3 Star Rating (9 Reviews)

By

Updated March 31, 2014

The Bottom Line

Despite what all the commercials say, Mederma is not any better than petroleum jelly for improving the appearance of scars.

Pros

  • Won't make the scar worse

Cons

  • Expensive compared to petroleum jelly
  • Extensive marketing campaign not backed by science
  • Time intensive - manufacturer recommends applying three times a day for 8 weeks on new scars

Description

  • The active ingredient is Allium cepa, or onion extract.
  • Onion extract has been shown to have anti-inflammatory properties and to improve collagen organization in a rabbit ear model.
  • There are no human studies that show onion extract improves the appearance of scars more than petroleum jelly.

Guide Review - Product Review: Mederma for Scars

Scars form on the skin through a three-stage process and this process can last up to two years after an injury. Many scientists are studying this wound-healing process in an attempt to find something that will make scars less visible. It is widely recognized that wounds heal best under moist conditions -- the skin fills in faster and scars are less visible.

In 2001, a study showed that onion extract used on rabbit ear scars improved collagen organization but didn't lead to a difference in scar appearance. So far, there have been three major controlled clinical studies in the United States evaluating the effect of onion extract on human wound healing. In all three, scars treated with onion extract did not show any improvement compared to scars treated with petroleum jelly. In fact, scars treated with petroleum jelly improved better than those treated with onion extract.

Based on these results, I do not recommend Mederma as a treatment for scars. You're probably better off just using petroleum jelly.

Sources:

Shih, Richard, and Joshua Waltzman. "Review of Over-the-Counter Topical Scar Treatment Products." Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery (2007): 1091-5.

Zurada, Joanna, David Kriegel, and Ira Davis. "Topical treatments for hypertrophic scars." Journal of the American Academy of Dermatology 55(2006): 1024-31.

User Reviews

 3 out of 5
Not indepth enough, Member clementineking

While this article is engaging, it raises more questions than it answers. I could not find (in the article or on this website) information regarding petroleum and it's ""documented"" success in treating scars. And there is nothing mentioned for either product regarding whether or not success rates would be affected by timing of application (during scar formation, new scar, old scar) or location on the body. I am left still perplexed, and don't really know how the products compare, or how to use them ideally.

Write a review

0 out of 0 people found this helpful.
Was this review helpful to you? Yes | No

See all 9 reviews

  1. About.com
  2. Health
  3. Dermatology
  4. Anti-Aging / Beauty
  5. Skin Care Products
  6. Treating Scars - Mederma Review

©2014 About.com. All rights reserved.

We comply with the HONcode standard
for trustworthy health
information: verify here.